Tuesday May 05, 2026
Sticker Shock: Fighting Your Indiana Tax Bill
If you opened your property tax bill this year and thought, there’s no way this is right… you’re not alone.
In this solo episode of the Indy REI Podcast, Jeremy Tallman breaks down a real situation he and his business partner faced when their tax bill jumped over 100% overnight—and exactly what they did about it.
Jeremy walks through:
-Why your property tax bill might be higher than expected
-The 1%–2%–3% rule (and why you’re probably paying more)
-What you can—and can’t—appeal
-The exact process to file an appeal in Indiana
-5 practical tips to give yourself the best shot at winning
If you own rental property in Indianapolis or anywhere in Central Indiana, this is one of those episodes that can literally save you money.
Because yes—taxes are part of the game. But overpaying doesn’t have to be.
Have questions about your property taxes or your rental portfolio? Drop them in the comments or reach out—we’re always here to help you invest with confidence.
No comments yet. Be the first to say something!